Soviet-bloc dissidents
condemn Castro
By Walter Skold. ©
2004 WorldNetDaily.com.
August 10, 2004.
On the eve of the world's largest library
conference, a group of prominent dissidents
from the former Soviet bloc have issued
a stinging rebuke to Fidel Castro for jailing
independent librarians and have called on
the International Federation of Library
Associations, or IFLA, to challenge Cuba
over its human rights violations.
"We know what it is like to live in
a society where freedom is repressed in
the name of democracy and national sovereignty,
and where the voicing of dissent is banned
in the name of safeguarding freedom of expression,"
says a letter released yesterday by the
Czech-based People In Need Foundation.
The letter, signed by such human rights
luminaries as Vaclav Havel, Elena Bonner,
Yuri Orlov, and the former prime ministers
of Bulgaria and Estonia, is being sent to
Paul Sturges, the head of the IFLA's Committee
on Free Access to Information and Freedom
of Expression, or FAIFE. The world library
group meets in Buenos Aires later this month
for its annual conference.
The appeal of former dissidents from Eastern
Europe, some of whom rose to be post-Soviet
leaders, charges that "the Cuban government
has made a systematic effort to crush the
independent library movement through a campaign
of harassment, threats, police raids, physical
assaults, arrests, and the confiscation
of library materials and library records."
The writers cite "shocking details"
in newly revealed documents smuggled from
Cuba that report how the "collections
seized from Cuba's independent librarians
were analyzed by court-appointed 'literary
experts' and officially condemned as 'subversive'
and 'counterrevolutionary' before, in many
cases, being ordered to be destroyed by
incineration."
This latest rebuke is a political setback
for the Cuban regime and comes after a year
of souring relations with European nations
as numerous human rights groups, prominent
writers and Western European governments
have condemned Cuba over a spring 2003 crackdown
in which 75 leading independent journalists,
librarians and activists were given show
trials and jailed.
The appeal from such respected European
human rights activists on the eve of International
Federation of Library Associations' annual
convention is likely to cause a small political
war in the library community. Not only will
the founder of the Independent Libraries
of Cuba, Humberto Colas, be attending, but
the new president of the American Library
Association, Carol Brey-Casiano, as well
as leaders from official Cuban libraries,
also are set to give important speeches.
Small but vocal groups of pro-Castro officials
within the ALA and other national library
groups have provided the Cuban dictator
with some of his best public-relations cover
in recent years, even while many former
Castro supporters and professional groups
have condemned him for his human rights
record.
"As the worldwide voice of librarians
and a leading defender of the right to freedom
of expression, especially in relation to
libraries, FAIFE/IFLA has a duty to speak
out clearly on Cuba," says the appeal
to Sturges.
In January, the Cuban government was furious
that IFLA challenged Castro's crackdown
of unofficial Internet use by urging Cuba
"to eliminate all obstacles to access
to the Internet imposed by its policies."
"While the World Summit of the Information
Society was debating how best to improve
access to information using information
technology, the Cuban government was preparing
a law that will further restrict Internet
access for its citizens," wrote Sturges
at the time.
Top officials of Cuba's state library system
have staunchly denied that the independent
librarians were victims of human rights
violations, or that they are "real
librarians," and have repeated vigorously
in international library conferences the
government claim that the activists were
"paid agents of the United States"
jailed for subversive activities.
"As for the Cuban government's efforts
to portray the independent librarians as
traitors and foreign agents because they
receive support from abroad," the letter
says, in response to such arguments, "We
speak from our own experience in rejecting
such claims. It can never be a crime to
oppose censorship or to open a library."
"We are familiar with the arguments
and strategies used by repressive regimes
to deny, evade responsibility for, and cover
up the existence of pervasive censorship
and repression, including the censorship
of government-run libraries," added
the signers, all of whom struggled against
communist information and political monopolies
in their respective nations.
"Like the people of Cuba, we have
lived under governments where newspapers
and the mass media are allowed to express
only one point of view, and where books
and magazines are harshly censored,"
they wrote, adding, "We are also familiar
with government-run library systems, based
on the model developed in the former Soviet
Union, designed to prevent the general public
from reading materials considered objectionable
by the regime in power."
This latest denunciation is the second
public relations disaster in one week for
Cuban efforts to rehabilitate their image
among usually supportive library groups,
as the American Library Association also
released letters last Thursday in which
they called on Cuban authorities to respect
intellectual freedom and "ensure the
health and welfare of these detained individuals."
The ALA's International Relation's Committee
was responding to an emergency appeal sent
in June from Gisela Sablon Delgado, the
director of the Independent Libraries of
Cuba, in Havana. Her husband is an Amnesty
International prisoner of conscience who
was sentenced to a lengthy term in April
2003 after government agents destroyed their
library collection, which was open to the
public.
In a letter to Cuban Minister of Foreign
Affairs Felipe Roque, IRC-chairman John
W. Berry expressed "deep concern"
over the treatment of prisoners. The letter,
which also speaks of ALA's position against
U.S. policies towards Cuba, marks only the
second time since the independent library
movement began in 1989 that the ALA has
come officially to the aid of the dissident
librarians.
A previous appeal from Delgado-Sablon in
June 2003 was ignored after detractors within
the ALA squashed attempts to give legitimacy
to people they argued were not even librarians,
but merely political opportunists receiving
money and books from the U.S. government
and exile groups hostile to Castro.
At that time, ALA President Mitch Freedman
had welcomed the head of the Communist party-controlled
national library to address the ALA in Toronto,
while refusing to give Colas a platform
to respond to charges made against the independent
libraries, which now number over 200.
Sablon's recent letter to the ALA said,
"Thanks to international attention,
three librarians have been liberated, including
Leonardo Bruzon Avila, Julio valdez Guevara,
and Juan Carlos Gonzalez Leiva, all of them
in serious health condition," but she
added that "more international attention
is required to bring about the release of
those remaining."
The Eastern European signers and those
librarians who are supportive of Cuba's
unique independent library movement are
hoping that a potential IFLA statement on
human rights would persuade Castro to release
more prisoners of conscience and allow the
libraries to operate freely.
"Despite the Cuban government's lengthy
and skillful campaign to deny, cover up
and mislead the international community
with regard to systematic censorship and
repression on the island," the statement
said, "The regime must be held accountable
for its own actions."
The appeal is being made, in part, under
provisions of a 1983 IFLA resolution which
says, "intervene when appropriate with
competent authorities on behalf of these
colleagues."
It is likely that in the lead-up to the
IFLA's upcoming convention in Buenos Aires
the Cuban government will respond with hostility
to this latest statement. The signers of
the statement have enormous stature within
the international community; however, some
observers say the stage is set for a showdown
in Argentina.
Loud shouting matches and even fights have
broken out on previous occasions in Mexico
and Geneva when Cuban officials have been
publicly challenged over human rights abuses.
Also, Brey-Casiano, unlike her predecessors,
speaks Spanish and has a sympathetic attitude
towards the independent library movement
in Cuba.
The appeal also will likely get a welcome
response from Cuba's beleaguered and divided
opposition groups, who generally look to
former dissidents like Havel and Bonner
as examples of citizens who fought, and
won, against communist repression.
Havel is a poet and writer who is credited
with leading his country's "Velvet
Revolution" in 1989, which separated
it from the Soviet Union. In his last American
speech as Czech president, given in Florida,
he singled out Cubans trying to build a
"civic society" for praise.
"I think that one of the most diabolical
instruments for subjugating some people
and fooling other is the special communist
language," said Havel, in the 2002
speech. "To all those who have not
lost the will to resist arbitrary force
and lies, may your dreams be fulfilled."
Walter Skold is an independent journalist
and librarian living in Freeport, Maine.
He was a reporter for the New York City
Tribune and taught journalism in China.
Related stories:
Librarians:
Anti-Castro columnist 'hyperbolic'
Award
rejected over group's bow to Castro
Librarians
ignore plea of Cuban prisoners
U.S.
Castro backers squelch prisoners' plea
American
librarians silence Cuban pleas
© 2004
WorldNetDaily.com, Inc.
|