Amnesty
International. April 3, 2003.
In the aftermath of the wave of mass arrests that began on
18 March 2003 in Cuba, Amnesty International is concerned
that 77 people may be prisoners of conscience, detained for
the non-violent exercise of their rights to freedom of expression
and association. In what has been labelled by dissident groups
as the biggest crackdown in a decade, at least five dozen
people from different provinces across the country have been
detained in a major police operation. Those detained include
journalists, owners of private libraries and pro-democracy
members of illegal opposition parties, including promoters
of the Proyecto Varela.(1) All of the detainees remain imprisoned
without charge, and the whereabouts of some of them is unknown.
According to reports, security agents searched homes across
the island detaining people and confiscating computers, fax
machines, typewriters, books and papers. Annex 1 of this document
is a list of all the known detainees, compiled by the Comisión
Cubana de Derechos Humanos y Reconciliación Nacional (CCDHRN),
Cuban Commission for Human Rights and National Reconciliation,
a national human rights organization. Among the detained are
several former prisoners of conscience including economist
Marta Beatriz Roque Cabello, who was sentenced for three years
and six months imprisonment in 1997 for 'other acts against
State Security,' 'otros actos contra la seguridad del estado;'
independent journalist Raúl Rivero Castañeda; and leading
organizer of the Proyecto Varela, Héctor Palacios Ruiz.
At least two members of the CCDHRN, Marcelo Cano Rodríguez
and Marcelo López Bañobre, have also been detained.
Those detained could face up to 20 years in prison under
harsh legislation introduced in 1999. In an unprecedented
event, the Cuban Government announced their detention on national
television and accused them of being linked to 'actividades
conspirativas,' 'acts of conspiracy,' through their contact
with James Cason, the Head of the US Interests Section in
Havana (see Background section below for more information).
The official communiqué stated that they would be 'brought
to trial,' 'sometidas a los tribunales de justicia'
and that the laws against 'complicity with the enemy,' 'complicidad
con el enemigo,' were still 'fully in force,' 'plenamente
vigentes,' and could be used. Felipe Pérez Roque, Cuban
Foreign Affairs Minister, later confirmed from Geneva that
those detained 'se enfrentarán a los cargos previstos por
las leyes cubanas para quienes han colaborado con una potencia
extranjera en contra de su patria,'(2) 'will be subjected
to the appropriate charges under Cuban law for those who have
collaborated with a foreign power against their homeland.'
In addition to the detentions, other high profile opposition
figures have been harassed. Plainclothes security agents were
posted outside the homes of Oswaldo Payá Sardiñas, leader
of a citizens' initiative on democratic change; former prisoner
of conscience Elizardo Sánchez Santacruz, of the CCDHRN, a
prominent human rights organisation in Cuba that is illegal
but tolerated by the authorities; and former prisoner of conscience
Vladimiro Roca Antúnez, son of the late Cuban Communist Party
leader Blas Roca.
This crackdown comes only a few months after a mass arrest
of activists in December 2002, when Oscar Elías Biscet González,
president of the unofficial Fundación Lawton de Derechos
Humanos, Lawton Human Rights Foundation, was detained
with 16 other dissidents after they attempted to meet in Havana
to discuss human rights. In addition, in February 2002 numerous
known dissidents were arrested in sweeps by state officials
following an incident in which a busload of youths crashed
into the Mexican Embassy in Havana, apparently in search of
asylum.(3)
Recommendations
Amnesty International seeks immediate information from the
Cuban authorities regarding the recent detention of all concerned,
the charges against them and the legal grounds on which they
will be tried. The organisation believes that the detainees
may be prisoners of conscience, detained solely for exercising
their rights to freedom of expression, assembly and association.
Please see Annex 1 for a full list of names.
In addition Amnesty International urges the Cuban authorities
to immediately and unconditionally release all prisoners of
conscience in Cuba: This includes the 15 previously named
by the organisation,(4) as well as of anyone else who is detained
or imprisoned solely for having peacefully exercised their
rights to freedom of expression, association or assembly.
Please see Annex 2 for a full list of those that AI has been
able to confirm as prisoners of conscience.
Amnesty International calls on the authorities to reform
the Cuban legislation which helps to "legitimise"
the ongoing incarceration of prisoners of conscience by outlawing
the exercise of fundamental freedoms.
Background
Proyecto Varela
The Proyecto Varela is a petition for referendum on legal
reform which seeks greater personal, political and economic
freedoms, as well as amnesty for political prisoners. It is
led by Oswaldo Payá Sardiñas, of the Movimiento Cristiano
Liberación, Christian Liberation Movement. In March 2002
project organisers reported having collected the 10,000 signatures
constitutionally required to hold a referendum.
Whilst activists for the Proyecto Varela have been subjected
to threats, short-term detention, summons, confiscation of
materials and other forms of harassment by State Security
agents, Oswaldo Payá has not been detained or harassed in
connection with his activities. Over recent months he has
gained increasing recognition in the international community.
In December 2002 he received the European Union's prestigious
human rights award, the Sakharov Prize, named after the late
Soviet dissident. In February of this year he carried out
a tour of 10 countries, during which he met the Pope, U.S.
Secretary of State Colin Powell and the heads of government
of Spain, Mexico and the Czech Republic.
Law 88
In February 1999 Cuba's National Assembly passed tough legislation
(Law 88), called the Ley de Protección de la Independencia
Nacional y la Economía de Cuba, Law for the Protection
of the National Independence and Economy of Cuba. The law
calls for seven to 15 years' imprisonment for passing information
to the United States that could be used to bolster anti-Cuban
measures such as the US economic blockade. This would rise
to 20 years if the information is acquired surreptitiously.
The legislation also bans the ownership, distribution or reproduction
of 'subversive materials' from the US government, and proposes
terms of imprisonment of up to five years for collaborating
with radio and TV stations and publications deemed to be assisting
US policy.
Relations with the European Union/Cotonou Agreement
This recent wave of mass arrests began just over a week after
the European Commission officially opened its first diplomatic
office in Havana on 10 March 2003. This was a positive step
in on-going relations between Cuba and the EU. The EU recently
welcomed Cuba's decision to apply for the Cotonou Agreement;
outlined the important strategic partnership between the EU
and Cuba in terms of trade, foreign investment, tourism development
co-operation; praised Cuba's achievements in sectors such
as health and education; and emphasised expectations for a
continuous political dialogue, stronger economic ties and
enhanced development.
However a declaration of 26 March by the Presidency on behalf
of the European Union concerning the arrest of opposition
members in Cuba stated 'violations of fundamental civil
and political rights will be monitored very closely by the
European Union and they will continue to influence the Union's
relations with Cuba.'(5)
The Cotonou Agreement is an economic assistance pact between
the European Union and African, Caribbean and Pacific (ACP)
nations. Cuba was formally admitted to the group of ACP states
on 14 December 2000 as the group's 78th member, after having
held observer status since May 1998. However, it is the only
ACP member which has not signed trade and aid agreements with
the EU. The Cotonou Agreement would potentially triple European
aid to Cuba. EU members have been divided over Cuba's entry
into the Cotonou Agreement, which clearly sets out that a
party signing the agreement needs to pay full respect to human
rights and fundamental freedoms, as laid down in international
conventions. In addition, well known dissidents within Cuba
had petitioned the European Union to deny Havana entry into
the Cotonou agreement on human rights grounds.
Cuba and the UN Commission on Human Rights
This wave of arrests began the day after the 59th session
of the UN Commission on Human Rights began in Geneva, Switzerland.
Since 1992 a resolution critical of Cuba's record has been
passed annually, with the exception of 1998. In 2002 Uruguay
presented a draft resolution on Cuba's human rights record
before the Commission which was supported by a wide range
of Latin American countries. Mexico, which for the past decade
had not voted in favour of the resolutions condemning Cuba's
record, was among those to vote in favour of the resolution.
Relations with the USA/US Interests Section
Cuba and the USA do not have diplomatic relations. However,
since 1977 the US has had an Interests Section based at the
Swiss Embassy in Havana; Cuba has an Interests Section in
Washington. In 2002 James Cason was named head of the US Interests
Section but was accused of undiplomatic behaviour by the Cuban
government after he made a high-profile visit to a meeting
of dissidents and spoke with international journalists gathered
there. Cason has met with opposition members around the island
and in the week before the mass arrests allowed a group of
dissident journalists to use his official residence for a
meeting, leading to sharp criticism from Fidel Castro. In
addition to these tensions, the Cuban government has become
increasingly disturbed by the imprisonment and solitary confinement
of five Cubans convicted in the US of spying on Cuban exile
groups in Florida. Their sentences range from 15 years to
life.
Annex 1
List of all known detainees arrested since
18 March 2003.
Nelson
AGUILAR RAMIREZ |
Pedro
Pablo ALVAREZ RAMOS |
Pedro
ARGÜELLES MORAN |
Víctor
Rolando ARROYO CARMONA |
Miajil
BARZAGA LUGO |
Margarito
BROCHE ESPINOSA |
Marcelo
CANO RODRIGUEZ |
Juan
Roberto DE MIRANDA HERNANDEZ |
Carmelo
DIAZ FERNANDEZ |
Eduardo
DIAZ FLEYTAS |
Antonio
DIAZ SANCHEZ |
Alfredo
DOMINGUEZ BATISTA |
Oscar
ESPINOSA CHEPE |
Efrén
FERNANDEZ FERNANDEZ |
Adolfo
FERNANDEZ SAINZ |
José
Daniel FERRER CASTILLO |
Luis
Enrique FERRER GARCIA |
Alfredo
Felipe FUENTES |
Orlando
FUNDORA ALVAREZ |
José
Ramón GABRIEL CASTILLO |
Próspero
GAINZA AGUERO |
Miguel
GALVAN GUTIERREZ |
Julio
César GALVEZ RODRIGUEZ |
Edel
José GARCIA DIAZ |
José
Luis GARCIA PANEQUE |
Ricardo
GONZALEZ ALFONSO |
Diosdado
GONZALEZ MARRERO |
Léster
GONZALEZ PENTON |
Alejandro
GONZALEZ RAGA |
Jorge
Luis GONZALEZ TANQUERO |
Leonel
GRAVE DE PERALTA ALMENARES |
Iván
HERNANDEZ CARRILLO |
Normando
HERNANDEZ GONZALEZ |
Juan
Carlos HERRERA ACOSTA |
Regis
IGLESIAS RAMIREZ |
José
Ubaldo IZQUIERDO HERNANDEZ |
Rolando
JIMENEZ POSADA |
Reinaldo
LABRADA PEÑA |
Librado
LINARES GARCIA |
Marcelo
LOPEZ BAÑOBRE |
Héctor
Fernando MACEDA GUTIERREZ |
José
Miguel MARTINEZ HERNANDEZ |
Mario
Enrique MAYO |
Luis
MILAN FERNANDEZ |
Rafael
MILLET LEYVA |
Nelson
MOLINET ESPINO |
Angel
Juan MOYA ACOSTA |
Félix
NAVARRO RODRIGUEZ |
Jorge
OLIVERA CASTILLO |
Pablo
PACHECO AVILA |
Héctor
PALACIO RUIZ |
Arturo
PEREZ DE ALEJO RODRIGUEZ |
Omar
PERNET HERNANDEZ |
Horacio
Julio PIÑA BORREGO |
Fabio
PRIETO LLORENTE |
Alfredo
PULIDO LOPEZ |
Arnaldo
RAMOS LAUSIRIQUE |
Blas
Giraldo REYES RODRIGUEZ |
Raúl
RIVERO CASTAÑEDA |
Alexis
RODRIGUEZ FERNANDEZ |
Omar
RODRIGUEZ SALUDES |
Marta
Beatriz ROQUE CABELLO |
Omar
RUIZ HERNANDEZ |
Claro
SANCHEZ ALTARRIBA |
Miguel
SIGLER AMAYA |
Guido
SIGLER AMAYA |
Ariel
SIGLER AMAYA |
Ricardo
SILVA GUAL |
Fidel
SUAREZ CRUZ |
Manuel
UBALS GONZALEZ |
Osvaldo
Alfonso VALDES |
Julio
Antonio VALDES GUERRA |
Miguel
VALDES TAMAYO |
Héctor
Raúl VALLE HERNANDEZ |
Manuel
VAZQUEZ PORTAL |
Antonio
Augusto VILLARREAL ACOSTA |
Orlando
ZAPATA TAMAYO |
Annex
2
List
of confirmed Amnesty International Prisoners of Conscience
current at March 2003
Yosvany
AGUILAR CAMEJO |
José
AGUILAR HERNANDEZ |
Bernardo
Rogelio AREVALO PADRON |
Oscar
Elías BISCET GONZALEZ |
Leonardo
BRUZON AVILA |
Francisco
Pastor CHAVIANO GONZALEZ |
Rafael
CORRALES ALONSO |
Carlos
Alberto DOMINGUEZ GONZALEZ |
Emilio
LEYVA PEREZ |
Eddy
Alfredo MENA GONZALEZ |
Carlos
OQUENDO RODRIGUEZ |
Ricardo
RAMOS PEREIRA |
Lázaro
Miguel RODRIGUEZ CAPOTE |
Néstor
RODRIGUEZ LOBAINA |
Jorge
Enrique SANTANA CARREIRA |
(1)
A petition for a referendum on fundamental freedoms. (See
Background section below for more information.)
(2)
"Castro aprovecha la crisis de Irak," El País, 23
March 2003.
(3)
See "CUBA: Continued detentions following mass arrests
in February and December 2002," AI Index AMR 25/001/2003,
27 February 2003.
(4)
See "CUBA: Continued detentions following mass arrests
in February and December 2002," AI Index AMR 25/001/2003,
27 February 2003; "CUBA: New prisoners of conscience
and possible prisoners of conscience," AI Index 25/008/2002,
6 November 2002; and "CUBA: The situation of human rights
in Cuba," AI Index 25/002/2002, 20 May 2002.
(5)
Brussels, 26 March 2003, press statement ref: 7735/03 (Presse
93) P 39/03. http://ue.eu.int/Newsroom
Link
to the report
|