CUBANET ... CUBANEWS

December 2243, 2002



When violence, dialogue fail, try disobedience

By Angel Pablo Polanco. The Miami Herald, December 24, 2002.

HAVANA -- Dissidents in Cuba and exiles in the United States say their dispersion is good.

''We are not divided, we are multiplying,'' they say, to justify the disproportionate number of opposition groups in Cuba -- more than 300 in a country of some 12 million people.

They also argue that the diversity of ways in which they combat Castro is an early exercise of democracy.

With those euphemisms, they try unsuccessfully to ignore the ugly side of their history, the schism that has affected Cubans since their first independence war in 1868.

Caudillismo -- the strongman syndrome -- is another of their secular ailments. Some people would rather be the head of a mouse than the tail of a lion and create their own organizations, even if only with two or three associates. This fire is also fanned by social-democrat and liberal winds that blow from Europe and the United States.

Such political currents help develop civilian society and disseminate democratic ideas. But they also encourage division by promoting the lifting of the embargo and a dialogue with Castro, issues on which most oppositionists split.

Oscar Elías Biscet, for example, a political prisoner with strong domestic backing, firmly supports the embargo. ''If the international community had acted toward Cuba in the same manner it did toward South Africa, our country would have been freed long ago,'' he said after his release in October.

(Editor's note: Biscet was arrested again on Dec. 6 while attempting to meet other dissidents. On Dec. 19, he was taken to Combinado del Este, a Havana maximum-security prison.)

Biscet, 42 and a physician, is a human-rights defender who rejects any accommodation with Castro.

Moderate dissidents, who favor the foreign leftist currents mentioned above, think quite differently. That these partisans exist is beneficial. But to attempt to practice democracy while Castro is in power is a mistake. Diversity -- God's creation -- exists independently of man. Yet the democratic system has to be built, and you can't mix one concept with the other, no matter how well the people get along.

Wanting to people do whatever comes to mind to each is like trying to topple Castro with spitballs.

History has shown that walls can be breached if many people strike on the same spot. And if the purpose of oppositionists and dissidents is to gain their freedom and consolidate a democratic system, the time has come for them to join ranks and march down the same road.

Luckily, those who yesterday followed the path of violence today admit -- with an honesty that does them proud -- that that's not the way to victory. For those who opted for the failed path of dialogue with the dictator, the honorable thing to do is to admit the same. And if we assume that those options -- violence and dialogue -- fail, the only path left for Cubans is peaceful civil disobedience, a form of struggle that the Castro regime has not defeated.

However, civil disobedience means more than staging street demonstrations. It also means finding the most suitable method of struggle and preparing to advance down that road. Because, to achieve freedom,the opposition must first carry out a conscience-raising campaign person to person.

This project, in time, can mobilize thousands of people who support the regime publicly but in reality do what they can against the system and wait for more probability of success before joining the struggle.

''These are not dreams,'' stresses Rogelio Menéndez Díaz, one of the advocates of civil disobedience.

''In any case,'' says Biscet, "they will come true, like those of Gandhi and Martin Luther King.''

Angel Pablo Polanco is an independent journalist in Havana.

[ BACK TO THE NEWS ]

Cuban independent press mailing list

La Tienda - Books, posters, t-shirts, caps

In Association with Amazon.com

Search:


SEARCH NEWS

Advance Search


SECCIONES

NOTICIAS
Prensa Independiente
Prensa Internacional
Prensa Gubernamental

OTHER LANGUAGES
Spanish
German
French

INDEPENDIENTES
Cooperativas Agrícolas
Movimiento Sindical
Bibliotecas
MCL

DEL LECTOR
Letters
Debate
Opinion

BUSQUEDAS
News Archive
News Search
Documents
Links

CULTURA
Painters
Photos of Cuba

CUBANET
Semanario
About Us
Annual report
E-Mail


CubaNet News, Inc.
145 Madeira Ave,
Suite 207
Coral Gables, FL 33134
(305) 774-1887